Historic Masonry Buildings Aren’t Unsafe. They’re Being Evaluated with the Wrong Tools.

Historic Masonry Buildings Aren’t Unsafe. They’re Being Evaluated with the Wrong Tools.

Alan Pettingale
Written by Alan Pettingale

February 9, 2026

Most problems I see in masonry restoration don’t start with failure. They start with misapplied codes.

Historic masonry buildings, multi-wythe brick, mass walls, lime mortars, were designed around different safety principles than modern construction. That doesn’t make them unsafe. It makes them different.

Yet too often, rehabilitation projects are forced down prescriptive code paths written for new buildings. The result is predictable:

  • Unnecessary demolition
  • Over-reinforcement
  • Loss of historic fabric
  • Projects that stall or become financially unviable

A recent national study on improving rehabilitation codes confirms what many of us see in the field: the original intent of the International Existing Building Code (IEBC), to remove barriers to reusing existing and historic buildings, has been steadily eroded.

There is a better option, and it’s already in the code.

The Performance Compliance Method (PeCM) evaluates buildings the way engineers actually think:

  • It assesses life safety holistically, not component-by-component
  • It allows deficiencies in one area to be offset by strengths in another
  • It recognizes that existing buildings often provide real, measurable safety,just not in modern prescriptive language

The Performance Compliance Code (PeCM) doesn’t lower the bar for safety. It measures safety differently, and more accurately, for existing buildings.

This matters now more than ever. Building reuse is tied directly to:

  • Housing supply
  • Carbon reduction
  • Preservation of durable, long-lasting structures

When historic masonry buildings are lost due to code misunderstanding, it isn’t a safety win, it’s a failure of diagnosis.

Good masonry restoration starts with asking the right question. Not “Does this building behave like a new one?” But “Does this building, as a system, provide acceptable life safety?”

That shift, from checklist compliance to informed evaluation, is where real problem-solving begins.

Alan Pettingale

Over thirty years of unconventional masonry restoration experience Alan Pettingale has become a top tier expert from all the knowledge and experience he has gained in over three decades of specialized experience within the world of masonry restoration. A craftsman, consultant, and educator, his work reflects not only technical mastery but a dedication to architectural integrity. From historic homes in Yorkshire to main streets in Texas, Alan’s journey shows the making of a true master of his trade.

Leave a Comment